I
am used to rubbish on TV. I watch quite a lot of it; when the brain
needs a rest and doesn't want silence, there is a wealth of
soothingly meaningless TV to watch on any number of channels. And if
you missed anything particularly soporific, you can watch it on +1 or
+2 or iplayer or whatever. But on Sunday I had a moment of horror
which has rarely if ever been surpassed in all my TV watching
history. (I'm a pensioner now, so my TV watching history is quite
long.)
I
don't normally do reality TV. Boring. Relentless minute peering into
the tawdry mental crevices of people I'm not remotely interested in.
But yesterday I walked into the room while one was on and had one of
the most horrifying experiences of my life. It was the kind of moment
that ordinary life does not prepare you for, frankly, a moment of
earth moving proportions that even a man of my decades of experience
should not have to suffer. Ever.
It
was The Voice. There were three of them. Yes, they had big voices.
Yes, they had energy. But all of that was as empty of merit as the
life of a mayfly for all the good it did in the face of the awful
treatment they gave to an iconic song. That sort of thing should
simply not be allowed. It was massacre, a soulless, plastic
demolition of one of the songs that defined its era, made worse by
the specious energy with which the massacre was carried out. They
attempted to perform Springsteen's Born To Run, and they strangled it
with a noose turned tighter with every overemphasised vowel and
mispronounced consonant.
It
should be enshrined in human rights legislation that people should
never be condemned to have this type of travesty thrust upon them. It
should be a cornerstone of our constitution that such a misbegotten
endeavour should never see the light of day, and if we have no
written constitution, we must write one just so that we can
incorporate this principle.
Born
To Run has soul, it has poetry. It is born from the streets that
Springsteen and his band trod. It flowers from the lives that he
recorded and celebrated so concretely and so poetically. It was not
and would never in a million years be so plastic, so fake, so
harrowingly overdone as it was on Sunday night. Springsteen spoke for
a generation because he was that generation. The first line “In the
day we sweat it out in the streets of a runaway American dream” (a
single voice with spare orchestration behind it). People loved that
line because it was his experience and it spoke to theirs. Sunday
night's lot haven't sweated anywhere except under stage lights. They
have made a plastic, fake, phony, sham, mendacious, distorted forgery
of a true poem. To reduce that to the fraudulent, meretricious
counterfeit that was served up on Sunday night with such hollow zest
is a cultural betrayal, an act of destruction beyond wanton.
Just
about everything gets copied nowadays, but there are some things that
just don't copy. A true original isn't just the words and the music
on a page. It's life, belting at you from the stage, out of bone and
sinew, out of the raw experience of being alive in that place at that
time, of feeling the hopes and the fears of a generation just finding
its feet in a time of turmoil, and beginning to wonder what comes
next.
“It’s
a death trap, it’s a suicide rap
We
gotta get out while we”re young...”
And
these three Sunday night simulacra, with their big voices and their
complete lack of connection with the fact that art emerges raw and
tumultuous from life, and they turned it to trash. The idea behind
The Voice and all those other reality contests is that you can
somehow turn ash into diamonds. All they did was turn a diamond into
ashes. Please don't tell me who they were. I don't want to know. I
don't ever want to hear anything like that done again.
I'm
going to listen to Bruce.
No comments:
Post a Comment